The next great baseball bar debate. Pro: a career 240-138 record equals 102 more wins than losses, he won 20 games twice and holds the career postseason record win 19 wins in the playoffs. Con: a career 3.88 ERA is high and he never won the Cy Young Award. And then there's the giant elephant in the room: his usage of HGH - which, to his credit, he admitted to, testimony that is central to the Roger Clemens' doping scandal.
In either case, let the argument begin!!!
Andy Pettitte career statistics